Eerie events in Somerset Harbor, Maine, force Maggie Watson to investigate some shady local history. With her college-age daughter's birthday fast approaching, Maggie Watson is combing the rooms of Sedgwick Manor and her shop, Carriage House Antiques, for the perfect gift. While exploring, Maggie discovers something peculiar: an old photograph of a stranger posed in one of the unused rooms on the second floor of Sedgwick Manor. After visiting that room, Maggie can't shake the feeling that some terrible memory is associated with the space. Meanwhile, Maggie takes in an injured tourist and soon learns that the woman has a secret family connection to Somerset Harbor and Sedgwick Manor. Maggie decides to investigate, but when frightening events start to occur at the manor, she begins to fear that the secret of the woman’s family history might be best kept locked away. This clever whodunit from Annie’s Antique Shop Mysteries series is a must-read for fans of cozy mysteries, antiques, New England, and female friendships.