Aunt Maggie left her niece Kelly everything she owned in Temptation, PA: her house, car, cash and even her insurance. She also left behind the Temptation Teapot Society which she founded and a mystery. The family treasure of a local family, the Weatherbys, is still hidden in Kelly's new home. Several people are looking for it and are willing to hurt anyone who gets in the way. Kelly and her husband, James, maybe with a little help from Miranda Hathaway, have to help the Weatherbys find their legacy if she is going to be able to enjoy her new life and the holidays!